HMRC’s Non-Statutory Clearance Service guidance lets a business ask for written advice on how the law applies to its own transaction. It is not a confirmation service, and an application that misses what HMRC asks for can be turned away or closed.

If you would rather we prepared the application, see our non-statutory clearance service.

What Is a Non-Statutory Clearance?

HMRC will give written advice if all of these apply: you have fully read the relevant guidance or contacted the relevant helpline, you have not found the information you need, and you are still uncertain how the legislation applies to your circumstances. You must be able to show a genuine uncertainty. In HMRC’s words, “Requests for reassurance or confirmation that your position is correct will not be accepted.”

HMRC says to check first that no more appropriate clearance route covers the transaction. Its page on clearance routes says the statutory clearances handled by its Clearance and Counteraction Team are concerned with anti-avoidance provisions relating to company reorganisations.

When Will HMRC Not Give a View?

HMRC will tell you why if it declines. The reasons it lists are that:

  • you have not given all the necessary information
  • HMRC does not think there is a genuine point of uncertainty, in which case it will explain why and direct you to the relevant guidance
  • you are asking for tax planning advice, or for HMRC to ‘approve’ tax planning products or arrangements
  • the transactions are, in HMRC’s view, for the purposes of avoiding tax
  • HMRC is checking your tax position for the period, in which case you contact the officer dealing with the check
  • any related return for the period is final (with an exception for offshore disclosures)
  • a statutory clearance applies to the transaction

HMRC also gives no clearance on matters of fact, such as whether certain activities amount to a business.

The guidance does not say the transaction must be large or commercially significant. The test is genuine uncertainty. It has no separate rule on hypothetical questions, but its tests all refer to your circumstances and your transaction, so a question with no real transaction behind it is unlikely to get far. You can apply before or after a transaction, as long as the related return is not final.

What Should the Application Contain?

HMRC withdrew Annex D, its VAT checklist, on 19 November 2026. The guidance now says VAT applications should be made using the online form, which you sign in to use. In our view, the best guide to what to include is the guidance itself and Annex A, HMRC’s checklist for other taxes, which still asks for the value of VAT-related transactions.

  • The business’s details: the name and address of the person carrying on the business, the VAT registration number and, if you act for a client, your contact details and authority to act. HMRC may phone, so give a daytime number.
  • The facts: why the transaction is being carried out, the relevant facts set out in order as transaction steps (for example what is supplied, the price and the contract terms), the proposed date if it has not happened yet, and its value.
  • The point of uncertainty: the legislation you think applies, why it is open to different interpretations, a summary of those interpretations, and why the treatment is uncertain, with reference to HMRC’s published guidance and case law.
  • Your own view: your view of the VAT consequences and the issues you want HMRC to consider.
  • Documents: copies of any legal advice you are happy to disclose, and details of any other advice or clearances you have sought from HMRC.

You must be satisfied that the information is, to the best of your knowledge and belief, accurate and correct.

How and Where Do You Send It?

Use HMRC’s online form for VAT non-statutory clearance. Older HMRC pages still give an email address and a BX9 postal address for clearance applications, but for VAT the current guidance points to the form. A Large Business Directorate customer with a Customer Compliance Manager sends its application to the relevant Large Business mailbox. To follow up, contact the caseworker or email nonstatutoryclearanceteam.hmrc@hmrc.gov.uk.

How Long Does HMRC Take?

The guidance says: “We’ll usually reply within 28 days unless there are any complicated issues involved. If there are, we’ll acknowledge your request and if possible tell you when to expect a full reply.” A 2022 update note on the same page said VAT requests were then taking around 12 weeks.

If HMRC needs more information, it says “we’ll suspend the handling time for your application until you’re able to give us the additional information that we’ve requested.” It must receive that information within 30 days of the date on its letter, and an application may be closed if it does not.

Waiting for a reply does not change the date by which you must pay your tax or send in your returns. If a return falls due first, send it on time and amend it later, within the normal time limits, if you need to.

How Far Does the Reply Bind HMRC?

The guidance does not use the word “binding”. It says you can rely on HMRC’s advice as long as the information you supplied is accurate and complete and you carry out the proposed transactions exactly as you describe them. A clearance applies only to the customer it was issued to.

The reply also reflects the law as understood when it was given. HMRC’s page on relying on its advice says that if the courts change that understanding, HMRC may no longer be bound by earlier advice, though it may apply the new view only going forward.

There is no general right of appeal against HMRC’s advice. If you disagree, you can file in line with your own view and draw HMRC’s attention to the entry. If you think HMRC overlooked reasons or facts you set out, you can ask the officer to look at the request again. Some VAT decisions are appealable by statute, and HMRC’s letter will say if yours is.

Practical Points

  • Frame the question tightly. One point, tied to the provision in doubt.
  • Show the guidance does not answer it. Name the guidance you read and explain why it does not settle your facts.
  • State your interpretation and the alternative, with your reasons.
  • Send everything at once. A request for more information suspends the handling time and starts a 30-day deadline.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is non-statutory clearance?

It is HMRC’s written advice on how the law applies to a specific transaction, where you have read the relevant guidance and are still genuinely uncertain. HMRC does not use it to confirm positions its guidance already covers.

How long does HMRC non-statutory clearance take?

HMRC says it will usually reply within 28 days unless there are complicated issues. If it needs more information, it suspends the handling time until you provide it, and it must receive the information within 30 days of its letter.

Is HMRC clearance binding?

HMRC says you can rely on its advice as long as the information you supplied was accurate and complete and you carry out the transaction exactly as described. It applies only to the business it was issued to, and HMRC may no longer be bound if the courts change the understanding of the law.

If you want help deciding whether to apply, or with the application itself, see our non-statutory clearance page.

Accountants: our VAT Helpline for Accountants answers questions like this on client files, on a retainer.

HMRC guidance checked as at 19 November 2026. This is general information, not advice for your circumstances.